Time Square Cafe Menu (Update 2026)

Time Square Cafe boasts an extensive menu that caters to diverse tastes. Each meal captures the essence of American comfort food, with hearty options like the Monte Cristo Sandwich and Blackened Cajun Chicken Sandwich. Breakfast items hold a special place here, with favorites like biscuits and gravy that patrons rave about.

The menu features various categories including sandwiches, quesadillas, breakfast burritos, and even seafood entrees. Average prices hover around $10, making this eatery budget-friendly without compromising on quality. With over 260 dishes, a visit here always promises something new to try.

Sandwiches
Quesadillas
Stir-Frys
Pasta Dishes
Appetizers
Wet Burritos
Breakfast Burritos
Arroz con…
Juicy Burgers
Dinner Entrees
Taco Salads
Skillets
Fajitas
Wraps
Sides
Omelets
Kids Menu
Soups
Mexican Sides
Seafood Entrees
Beverages
Steak & Eggs
Pancakes
Mexican Desserts
Clubs
Breakfast Sides
Tacos
Country Eggs
Desserts
French Toast
Chimichangas
Melts
Biscuits & Gravy
Mexican Appetizers
Fresh Salads
Kid’s Menu (Mexican)

Featured Dishes

Breakfast Burrito
Breakfast Burrito
Salad
Salad
Stir Fry
Stir Fry
Chicken Parmesan Dinner
Chicken Parmesan Dinner
Pancake Combo
Pancake Combo
Patty Melt
Patty Melt
Fried Chicken Dinner
Fried Chicken Dinner
Burban Chopped Steak Dinner
Burban Chopped Steak Dinner
Mushroom Swiss Burger and Fries
Mushroom Swiss Burger and Fries
French Toast
French Toast
10 Oz Chopped Steak
10 Oz Chopped Steak
Chopped Burban Steak
Chopped Burban Steak
Farmers Skillet
Farmers Skillet
Time Square Cafe Menu image 1
Time Square Cafe Menu image 2
Time Square Cafe Menu image 3
Time Square Cafe Menu image 4
Time Square Cafe

Time Square Cafe Interior, Food, Ambiance

Walking into Time Square Cafe, patrons often notice the relaxed, welcoming atmosphere that makes it feel like a hometown favorite. Decorated with local memorabilia, the cafe has an inviting charm complemented by carpeted flooring that adds warmth. Whether it's a family breakfast or casual dinner, the space tends to buzz with conversations and laughter.

The food taking center stage at this cafe not only satisfies hunger but also enriches the dining experience. The ambiance reflects a balance of comfort and liveliness, making it a great spot to unwind with friends or share a meal after a busy day in South Whitley.

Time Square Cafe

About Time Square Cafe Food and Specialties

The food at Time Square Cafe reflects a blend of American and Mexican influences, delivering comfort alongside bold flavors. Signature dishes like the Chopped Steak and the Club Sandwich stand out, each one crafted with quality ingredients that locals love. Don't miss the breakfast burritos, which pack a flavorful punch and start the day right.

Diners particularly enjoy the mashed potatoes that accompany many entrees, often described as creamy and perfectly seasoned. For those craving something with a kick, the fresh salsa and diverse taco offerings provide a delightful option, making lunch or dinner feel like a fiesta.

Time Square Cafe

Time Square Cafe is committed to serving exceptional food at reasonable prices. The diverse menu showcases a blend of classic American and Mexican dishes, ensuring there’s always something new to try. The specialty lies in the breakfast and comfort food offerings, which resonate with local traditions, making mealtime feel like a cherished gathering.

The vision emphasizes building community connections through shared meals, where everyone feels welcome. Regulars often share anecdotes and recommendations, building a sense of camaraderie. This cafe isn’t just about satisfying hunger; it aims to create meaningful experiences for everyone who walks through the door.